Tampa Sherriff's Department Gave Legal Advice to DUI Suspects

My colleagues at the Sammis Law Firm in Tampa, Florida alerted me to this practice by the Hillsborough County (FL) Sheriff's Office. It appears that the sheriffs took on a new role as legal advisors for their arrestees by handing out this flyer.

While nothing in the flyer is wrong, it’s incomplete and does not explain to the arrestee all of their legal options and secondary ramifications of electing to waive a formal review of the license suspension. And since when are police authorized to deliver legal advice to their prisoners?

What's Missing from This Notice?

It says nothing about the downside to electing to waive the formal review hearing. Waiving the Formal Review Hearing will result in a suspension for 6 months for a breath test over .08% and one year for a first refusal to submit to a chemical test.

It says nothing about the fact that this suspension will appear on your Florida driving record and could affect employment and insurance coverage. Some companies will treat the suspension as if it were a DUI conviction (which it's not) and not renew coverage.

It says nothing about the right to a formal review hearing to contest the legality of the suspension and that obtaining the business permit right now will toss that right in the garbage.

What Do You Give Up?

The Formal Review Hearing is a valuable discovery tool. The Bureau of Administrative Reviews will let us copy their entire file of police reports and breath testing/refusal. This gets me a leg up on prosecutors who won't see these documents for weeks. I also get to subpoena and take sworn statements of the police officers involved affording us a great opportunity for impeachment at a later time.

Since When Are Police Allowed to Dispense Legal Advice?

When my clients ask the police at the breath testing facility if they should take the breath test, the police invariably advise that they can't offer an opinion or give them advice. They tell my clients that if they refuse, their license will be suspended, which is all the law requires of them.

If a paralegal in my office were to give specific and material advice to a client about a legal matter, they might be subject to laws relating to the unauthorized practice of law. In these cases, the police are an adverse party who should steer clear of any advice or acts which could affect valuable legal rights.